[This article is Cross-posted to my monthly column at MarketingLand, which is a great place to read all sorts of interesting content.]
Everyone knows the question: “What one [book|person|food|movie|etc] would you take with you on a deserted island?” That is to say, what one thing can’t you live without?
Most of us have a pretty narrow list. Perhaps it’s a book you’ve read over and over again. Or your favorite cousin — the one you would like as a friend even if you weren’t related. Or chocolate chip ice cream (I assume the deserted island has a freezer and electricity!).
Have you ever asked yourself that question about your metrics? What one metric in your business can’t you live without? What measurement of success must you have to run your business, so much so that you’d be catatonic if it went away? Even for businesses in the same category, there’s no one right answer all the time. For some businesses, it’s Conversion rate. For others, it’s Revenue. Yet others prefer a blended number like Net Revenue per Customer. How about Repeat Customer rate? And some folks cheat and come up with a conditional “well if I was selling X, it’d be this, but if I were selling Y, then it’d be that.” No matter how you slice and dice your metrics, choosing one is a heck of a choice to have to make!
Now, we all have a hard time narrowing down a favorite movie or food or book to one . Usually, we can get to two or three “essential” items and hate having to make the final cut. Fortunately, too, the vast majority of us will never actually be stranded on a deserted island, so choosing wrong or flippantly or impractically doesn’t carry a big penalty.
But imagine if you choose wrong for your business. Now the stakes are far more real and dangerous. A “favorite” now has to justify itself and its impact on the business. It can’t hide behind “well we always look at that one” ( a logical fallacy known as “appeal to tradition”) or “I went to the Conversion Conference and heard that Landing Page Optimization is the only way to improve conversion!” (a logical fallacy known as “appeal to authority”) or “ABC Widgets Inc and XYZ Widgets LLC both use this metric, and I sell metrics, so this must be the right one!” (a logical fallacy known as “I’m a lemming and can’t be bothered to think for myself”).
Your One better be, well, The One.
And the act of winnowing down, and choosing a final singular metric upon which all metrics are subservient, is a laborious, thoughtful, even painful process. Imagine a cross between “Lord of the Flies” and “Lord of the Rings”.
I challenge you to try. If you can narrow down your list to one number, it means that all your other numbers must, per force, be useful only in supporting/refining/augmenting The One. Thinking of it that way, the other metrics you choose to be in supporting roles might well change, and give you a very different view of your business. If they aren’t supporting The One, what are they doing there?